If I had only $200 to spend, getting the Klipsch sub-12 on sale for $199.99 (which happens fairly often) would be my first choice. The Bic F12 is the best cheap subwoofer! my room is about 12 x 20 and it easily fills the room with good sound for music and movies. SO yes, despite having a 2" smaller driver the SVS is much better. The popular BIC America F12 (reviewed here) is equally excellent for the price, and also has that really cool metallic driver design if that’s something you like enough to consider, but is just barely inched out spec wise by both the Sub-1200 and Sub-1500. Despite being lesser known and having a website that looks like it’s stuck in 1997, BIC America has been around as long as the best of them and has managed to produce several really great value-tier loudspeakers. Can’t remember what he wants but it could be worth asking him. I AM speaking in facts, where you're just taking a quote from SVS and running with it. Compare. The driver is … Dayton Audio SUB-1500 15" 150 Watt Powered Subwoofer 4.6 out of 5 stars 99. If you want to hang out with /r/redditaudio on IRC, you can join #redditaudio on irc.freenode.net. Dayton Audio SUB-1500 vs BIC F12. Customers like Bic America F12 noticeably more Bic America F12, the pricier option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Bic America V-1220 [4.6 vs 4.4 ]. Sure you can put it anywhere but to get the best sound you might have to rearrange some stuff. Dayton Audio SUB-1500 15" 150 Watt Powered Subwoofer. Camera gear: https://goo.gl/oL286s Speaker gear: https://goo.gl/RtevBT Add … Oct 24, 2012 7 0 10,510 0. The bics don’t even compare to the hsu, it’s just a totally different sound going from a budget sub to a “true” sub. They never sounded bad but just lacked the real low end impact. BIC America F12 12-Inch 475-Watt Front Firing Powered Subwoofer 4.7 out of 5 stars 1,980. The BIC F12 is the better sub here. In my opinion neither, but if you are limited in budget, and can't spend the $$$$ i'd get the one that can play the loudest and lowest between the two. I had the F12 picked initially but then was told that since the 1500 is much larger, it should fill the room better. Dayton Audio has there own website which lists the same products that PE is selling -- no surprise there, given how they're linked -- but what is surprising is the fact that everything costs more if you purchase it from Dayton Audio. After setting it up and testing out the sound with different 4K movies with Dolby Atmos or DTS:X, the difference was considerable. Its in the basement so its on carpet,pad, then cement and I don't feel like the dayton is filling the room or making me feel like I'm in the movie during an explosion or a ship goes by. I would say that if you're space challenged then the 1500 wouldn't be the best choice. Still can't decide. save hide report. ... Only 10 left in stock - order soon. i have the f12 and i love it. Thanks for the reply. That little sub, 10" driver, can play down to 19hz and do so with authority. Looking to set up a budget HT for my daughters to watch Disney movies, etc. This subwoofer was the best in our test group at delivering long and low sustained bass notes during our movie listening test. I was thinking 15inch sub might be too big for my studio apartment which is about 350 sqft living room space. Let us also consider a much more linear comparison. Bic America F12, the pricier option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Dayton Audio 15" [ 4.5 vs 4.3 ]. Yeah I've heard that the 1500 is quite a bit more powerful than the 1200. IME. obviously it's more complex than X is better than Y in all circumstances. 1) different circumstances. Thanks for the reply. Either of the 4 has to be better than the klipsch ksw12 I have. This thread is archived. I would much rather have the lazier, but larger enclosure and higher output driver in the sub-1500 but that is, of course subjective. Even at it's best the f12 doesn't get above 100dB of output, where as the Dayton 1500 at 30hz down to 23hz stays flat and plays up to 106db of output. BIC V-80 8" Subwoofer 100 Watts. Just because a driver is bigger in diameter (a 15" vs a 12"), it doesn't mean that its heavier and has more mass. Cause its not very impressive as it … the 1500 is also a bigger cabinet, so even if you pull the BIC off the wall a bit, it won't have a much bigger footprint than the 1500, [–]GbMaxSE 0 points1 point2 points 2 years ago* (6 children). HW Reviewer. ... Only 10 left in stock - order soon. Any suggestions to improve sound or anything would be greatly appreciated! Yikes. ... Dayton SPA250 vs Yung SD300 Tested - Duration: 9:44. Bic F12 vs Dayton 1500? music/games. Sub: BIC F12 or Dayton Sub-1500. Also a bit more expensive. A stronger magnetic field is a function of the size of the magnet on the driver, not power. New to the forum. Yes, there are many 10" subs that outperform many 12's. Filter by All reviewers ... Dayton Audio SUB-1500 15" 150 Watt Powered Subwoofer. Need advice for speaker and headphone amp. Look at my comment in this thread where i provided ACTUAL measurement/response graphs/tables of the two subs in question. Even people who scoff, and say it’s not important, or that they aren’t interested, are quickly “converted” once they hear the difference. Your Price $198.90 (19 Reviews) Part # 303-432 Qty. 4.3 out of 5 stars 60. While there are some great budget options out there in the US, those options are not always available for the same prices else ware. The BIC F12 is hard to go wrong for the price (<$250 most places I've seen). Goal here for a good subwoofer is to get as close to and blow 20hz, effectively, with authority and doing so with very little variation in the frequency curve. I went with a BIC F12 and haven't looked back! Main thing here with the Dayton 1500 is that i'll play down to 23hz, the F12 doesn't. :), [–]ArmscGood sound makes everything better 0 points1 point2 points 2 years ago (0 children). Hide sidebar Show sidebar Thread starter Hookedup12; Start date Jul ... A sub 1500 would likely best both for less cost. Search. But, it certainly might be the best choice if you can get a good deal on it. Klipsch isn’t known for great subs, and bic has a decent reputation, but only in the budget realm. $209.99. i keep my down to around 50% volume, so it's got plenty of power to boot. The main thing to note here, is that the frequency range you "feel" that envelops you, and makes an "impact" are 25hz and lower, ideally 20hz. Williston Audio Labs 245,477 views. not about this specific comparison) I'll gladly concede that I'm wrong. Dayton Audio SUB-1500 vs BIC F12. The sealed design affords it a much smaller enclosure. > not necessarily poorly designed, rather different costs. In any case, both solutions would be perfect for middle or even large areas. The Dayton is a better subwoofer in terms of capability. the Sub 1500 is a much larger cabinet with a much larger woofer. This is fair, but it's the best I could do. While there is no upper price limit, realistically we focus on speakers in the sub $1000 range, with the sweet spot being between $150 to $500. 1 offer from $414.69. The PB outperforms the SB in most facets aside from overhang and response time. Besides one Velodyne model under $500, there other lesser offerings are about equal to the SW150. March 26, 2014 10:36 a.m. PT. Dayton Audio has there own website which lists the same products that PE is selling -- no surprise there, given how they're linked -- but what is surprising is the fact that everything costs more if you purchase it from Dayton Audio. It has got to be better than my Samsung flat screen's speakers while my Onkyo receiver gets worked on. I would just caution you on making against making assumptions just on physical measurements of a subwoofer. The Audiophiliac spends quality time with Dayton Audio's 15-inch subwoofer. Besides one Velodyne model under $500, there other lesser offerings are about equal to the SW150. Hide sidebar Show sidebar Thread starter Hookedup12; Start date Jul ... A sub 1500 would likely best both for less cost. But you do move two more inches of airspace with the Dayton hmm decisions. They will sound as good as any of the subs. BIC F12 BIC V1120 During shopping also found: BIC RTR-EV1200 ... BIC vs KLIPSCH vs ? I added one more star for the full refund resolution. I would rank the EV1200 above the Dayton sub-1200/1500, but below the Bic V-1220. But the laymans translation of what they are saying is literally JUST "A better designed subwoofer will trump a poorly designed one, every time.". Yes that is the case. [–]ldeas_man 1 point2 points3 points 2 years ago (5 children), if you can provide me with some material that shows I'm wrong, I'll gladly read it. It could be argued that the BIC F12 looks a little better with its golden driver but that all comes down to preference. Unfortunately my sub placement is rather limited to one corner in the front of the room. Audio. The BIC America F12: Full Review | Get it on Amazon. I had the F12 picked initially but then was told that since the 1500 is much larger, it should fill the room better. The SUB-1200 utilizes a bass reflex design with a … Dayton sub 1500 vs bic america f12 I'm currently running 2.0 setup with jbl studio 580 with pioneer vsx 5900s receiver. Both of these speakers are a great budget buy with the same RMS power of 150w. [–]ldeas_man -1 points0 points1 point 2 years ago* (2 children). MANDATORY Compare Dayton Audio SUB-1500 vs BIC America F12 subwoofer side-by-side. BIC V-80 8" Subwoofer 100 Watts. A smaller [Diameter] (aka a 10" vs a 12") driver doesn't mean lighter. I've been told my expectations maybe too high. Dayton Audio SUB-800 8" 80 Watt Powered Subwoofer 4.7 out of 5 stars 106. FWIW, @Reckel, a member here, has QTY-4, BIC pl200 for sale. We spent dozens of hours researching and comparing SUB-1500 vs F12 for you to find the right one for your entertainment room. A newbies suggested product list. None of these subs in this price range are going to wow you with low LFE for movies. Compare. I know it might be a bit of a gimmick right now but I really want to try it.). specifically these lines: "Poorly designed big subwoofer drivers with inadequate motors don’t produce accurate bass and struggle to start and stop on a dime. all things being equal, certain design choices will hold benefits over over design choices. BIC America F12 12-Inch Front Firing Powered Subwoofer Review Bottom Line: The F12 is really well built for the price, and is one of the best budget-tier subwoofers on the market. A new BIC F12, Dayton 1200/1500, and others up to $250 (used on Amazon is fine, too). Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking Bic America F12 is more popular IME. I'd put money on the fact that you're an engineer. One has a better driver and enclosure and amp, the other is the BIC F12. It has got to be better than my Samsung flat screen's speakers while my Onkyo receiver gets worked on. a woofer is just a mass-spring-damper system, and mass is a huge factor in how that system responds. $239.95. It's likely the best sub you can get for $200. Now I'm looking at the BIC PL-200 II as well. both of those material costs increase the total cost, leaving less money to go towards the amp and the magnets. It could fit the 1500. y agreg. If you just really want a super cheap computer solution (Creative Labs, Altec Lansing, etc.) You need to look at the total dB (volume) output across the frequency range as well as total extension of the subwoofer. The subs are very comparably priced, and the SUB-1500 is definitely bigger, AND has a bigger driver. It's a big box. It's just $179 shipped! Dayton SUB-1200 vs SUB-1500, worth the upgrade to 15"? post to, If you are looking for advice on sound bars please post to, Feel free to post links to sales and good deals. Actually the driver has to be that close (since the port has no contribution that high in frequency) which is not even possible with many subs unless they're turned sideways! A stronger magnetic field is a function of the size of the magnet on the driver, not power. The Overall Best Budget Subwoofer – The Dayton Sub-1500. The Dayton SUB-1500 has a bigger woofer but the BIC F12 has a better amp and driver, and the driver is easier to control due to its smaller size. If we put it 2ft away we'll get a cancellation centered around ~70Hz... not good. This is an excellent subwoofer in it’s own right, though slightly inferior to the sub-1500. Also keep in mind that the ideal spot for the sub may not be where you want it. The Dayton's frequency range does go down a bit more. share. Without looking up the specs I BELIEVE the SV gets a little louder in the midrange, but falls short elsewhere. mine is close to a wall on one side, but the ported rear is about 2-3ft from the wall. The BIC America F-12 had an impressive showing in our listening tests. Previous Next Sort by votes. R-112sw vs bic f12. The Dayton Audio SUB-1500 15" powered subwoofer delivers massive, room-shaking bass in any room, even large home theaters. NO AFFILIATE LINKS, but if you find a great deal on something and want to share use. Dayton Audio Box Subwoofer Series (SUB-800-1000-1200-1500) Review Last updated on: 7-5-20 Bottom Line: Dayton Audio is a great company, and each of their four sized box subwoofers have some of the best specs and design that we’ve seen for the price. Agree with this. you need to understand that subwoofers are a sum of their parts and their designs, and there are few rock-solid absolutes. Both get good budget reviews. Neither the 12" dayton nor the sub-1500 will meet those expectations. Both get good budget reviews. [–]LouGossetJr -1 points0 points1 point 2 years ago (0 children). May 8 Mon Central meeting, Temple Hills, MD May 12 & 13 ON4UN speaks in MD and VA. See article in this issue. The BIC F12 is hard to go wrong for the price (<$250 most places I've seen). I ended up buying two vtf3-mk5s from hsu and they’re awesome. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the hometheater community. Case in point the SVS PB-1000, touted as the beast for $500. The C1500K however, is a sealed sub, and a bit smaller than the ported 1500. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. $239.95. Space is a bit constricted in the room, and it would fit flush against the wall. Basement room 12x15 with 9ft ceilings, carpet, drywall. P. pwx Honorable. The Dayton Sub1200 goes on sale for $135 occasionally. If someone is being helpful and you agree with their advice, then Upvote it. Your Price $239.95 (179 Reviews) Part # 300-634 Qty. The Dayton Audio SUB-1200 12-inch subwoofer is a step up from the other budget subs we tested in a few ways. Although both are 12 inch subwoofers, the Dayton's definitely does a better job. Simply put, the F12 is awesome. What do you use for LCR and surrounds? there's that Nixxuz guy that posts here that has the dayton 15 and bic rtr12 which is just like the f12 and he seems to recommend the f12/rtr12 over the Dayton. Yamaha receiver, either bookshelves or in-ceiling speakers. You literally just proved my point: RE- generalizations. Dayton Audio SUB-1500 15" 150 Watt Powered Subwoofer 4.6 out of 5 stars 99. Your one stop for all things Home Theater (except soundbars). The BIC also has a higher quality of fit and finish than the Dayton, because they spent more money on aesthetics. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking Bic America F12 is more popular Look at my comment in this thread where i provided ACTUAL measurement/response graphs/tables of the two subs in question. Acoustic Audio PSW-15 Down Firing Powered Subwoofer (Black) 4.2 out of 5 stars 1,132. Your Price $198.90 (19 Reviews) Part # 303-432 Qty. Set your expectations too high. REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 6389 on r2-app-0a9720a87de327282 at 2020-12-05 18:21:36.682023+00:00 running a7f2daa country code: NL. The reason the F12 gets so much praise is that is "sounds" loud, because is has a big boost in output around 35 - 40hz, but once it gets below 35hz it starts to fall off dramatically. Parts express/dayton subs are often recommended because they outperform their price segments. Once I get the receiver back, I should have both the Daytons set up and ready to go. More power does NOT mean more control. Camera gear: https://goo.gl/oL286s Speaker gear: https://goo.gl/RtevBT Add … Page 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1 . Dayton 1500 vs bic f12? BIC America F12 vs Dayton Audio SUB-1500 Subwoofers comparison side-by-side: which subwoofer is better for you considering specs and features? I can switch back and forth between my much more expensive Klipsch RP-160m speakers (flat to about 35hz in my room) in direct mode with no xover and the sub 1500 crossed at 60hz and hear no change in the quality and accuracy of the bass when listening to music. A smaller driver doesn't mean lighter. Based on our rating, both have the same overall rating of 7.3 out of 10. I’d probably go for the SUB-1500. maybe not, but it is a fact that if you spend more on one element, you'll have less to spend on the others. You're making dangerous, sweeping generalizations here. Everyone wants better bass, whether they realize it or not. Read more. Prime example is an SVS pb1000 vs the F12 in question in this thread. edit: if you can provide a source that shows that I'm wrong (in general. http://averagejoeaudiophile.blogspot.com/, Dayton Sub-1500 Frequency Response thread (without Graph, sadly). But then I was told that, while the 1500 is larger, the F12 is much better built and would therefore have longer reach and better sound. You’re definitely working in a tough price range, but for that money I’d buy the Daytons all day long. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking Bic America F12 is more popular One of the main parameters that we need to compare is the power and that is the place where we can see the difference – 120 W Dayton audio sub-1200 vs BIC F12 that produces 150 W continuous or 475 W of the dynamic peak power. This is a subreddit for all budget minded audiophiles and enthusiasts looking to grow into real speakers and separate components; and out of boomboxes, bluetooth speakers and PC branded audio solutions. In our awesomeness score Bic America F12 ranks #20 out of 182 and Bic America V-1220 ranks #60 out of 182. yes and I saw them. You're making the assumptions that the Sub-1500 is more poorly designed in driver and enclosure than the Bic F-12. Klipsch R-41PM with Topping D10s DAC. In fact subs should generally be placed close to boundaries to avoid cancellation from the reflected wave against said boundary, http://www.mh-audio.nl/CancellationFreq.asp. In our awesomeness score Polk Audio PSW10 ranks #14 out of 182 and BIC America H-100II ranks #85 out of 182. May 19-21 Dayton 2000 Hamvention, Dayton, Ohio May 27-28 CQWW WPX CW Contest. SUGGESTED to help keep things a bit more organized New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. BIC America F12 12-Inch 475-Watt Front Firing Powered Subwoofer 4.7 out of 5 stars 1,983. I have $XXX.XX to spend, what should I buy? [–]GbMaxSE 0 points1 point2 points 2 years ago* (2 children). For what its worth, I just purchased the 12 inch Dayton, my room is L shaped and around 20X24 with the corner cut out. and more power will result in a stronger magnetic field. Next. level 2. Bic V-1220 would be my second choice. the Sub 1500 is a much larger cabinet with a much larger woofer. No one is RUSHING to review and provide bench-quality independent lab tests of two ultra-budget subwoofers. Once I get the receiver back, I should have both the Daytons set up and ready to go. the BIC has more power and a smaller woofer, so it's going to be a lot tighter and better for dynamic sounds e.g. BIC F12 Frequency Response Thread, [–]TactFully 3 points4 points5 points 2 years ago (1 child), ... except 1 note, the distance-to-wall thing is a myth; only a few inches are needed for the air to escape. Rendered by PID 6389 on r2-app-0a9720a87de327282 at 2020-12-05 18:21:36.682023+00:00 running a7f2daa country code: NL. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. More power does NOT mean more control. conversely, the smaller woofer and cabinet on the BIC F12 means there's more money for the amp and magnet. Thread starter pwx; Start date Jan 1, 2019; Sidebar Sidebar. I'm not going to post anything that will speak contrary to what SVS is saying... what they posted is entirely accurate. 99.9% movies, TV, gaming. The response graph for an F12 is MOUNTAINOUS, and extraordinarily bloated in the midrange. In our awesomeness score Bic America F12 ranks #37 out of 172 and Dayton Audio 15" ranks #59 out of 172. BIC America F12 vs Dayton Audio SUB-1500 Subwoofers comparison side-by-side: which subwoofer is better for you considering specs and features? F12 has got a 12 inches long throw woofer. Dayton Audio Sub-1500, a maximum-fun subwoofer. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, 65" MU8000, UBD-K8500, X1400H, Philharmonic AAM, PB-1000, OWM3, Klipsch RF45 Towers, RC-45, RB-45 Surrounds | Dual SVS PB12-NSD. by Dayton Audio. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking Polk Audio PSW10 is more popular Basement room 12x15 with 9ft ceilings, carpet, drywall. and less weight means lower moment of inertia, making it easier to start/stop, which in turn results in better control. Note all of the above I just said is soley based off of the measure frequency response and output, which if you knew how to read that and understood it, you'd realize that the Dayton 1500 was clearly a better subwoofer and your myth around smaller driver and more amplifier is completely wrong and all you're doing is spreading misinformation. 10 comments. Amazon, Newegg, Slickdeals, Woot etc. During this test, we played a scene from the James Bond movie Skyfall that has a 15-second sustained low-frequency rumble effect. Ly Eo lo os n p er ste puerto Ileva cargo que 1q4 vs tambidn dirigido a El gobierno revel quo los Cheque en CregcMllan proyret o menlo se gnora si hubo victi- hondas. my understanding of mechanics leads me to believe that a smaller (and lighter) woofer with more power controlling it will lead to better response, as there's less moving mass and a stronger magnetic field. The F12 is more comparable to the $200 Dayton 1500, and I will say that Dayton is almost definitely better because the cabinet has ~73% more volume than the BIC. Customers like Bic America F12 somewhat more Bic America F12, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Dayton Audio 15" [4.6 vs 4.6 ]. Dayton Audio SUB-1000L 10" 100 Watt Low-Profile Powered Subwoofer ... BIC Venturi V1220 12" Powered Subwoofer 200W. $1,500 5.1 "Expandable" Recommended System YouTube Discussion ... in usa and carry to india so i am limited in size.total shipping dimension should not exceed 62inch. $239.95. use the following search parameters to narrow your results: Official subreddit for http://averagejoeaudiophile.blogspot.com/, Official Facebook Group at Budget Audiophile. I'm talking about size in general. (All affiliate sales/links will be removed). [–]ldeas_man -1 points0 points1 point 2 years ago (7 children), the BIC has more power and a smaller woofer, so it's going to be a lot tighter and better for dynamic sounds e.g. [–]GbMaxSE 1 point2 points3 points 2 years ago* (0 children). sealed enclosures provide additional damping, so the designs aren't exactly comparable. Looking at the BIC F12 vs Dayton 1200. Both of these speakers are a great budget buy with the same RMS power of 150w. Quoting SVS is fine and all, but you need to understand that subwoofers are a sum of their parts and their designs, and there are few rock-solid absolutes looking JUST at a few numbers. I'm not really sure what point you're making here.